Native Forest Council news forest voice act! learn more join/give about us
new visitor contact us news group sign up links  
Forest Voice
current issue current issue pdf archive submission guidelines distribute FV
Forest Fires


Federal Fire Sham

by Ed Dorsch

Billions Wasted

The $2 billion to $3 billion a year that the Forest Service and other federal land agencies spend on fires is mostly wasted, says a new report from the Oregon-based Thoreau Institute. Last year, Congress gave the Forest Service a $1.4 billion, 38 percent increase in its budget, mostly for fire, on the promise that spending more money now will reduce future fires and fire costs. But that's a promise the Forest Service can't keep.
Read the full story

Logging and Fire Risk

Does logging really decrease fire danger? Overwhelming evidence indicates the opposite. Forests with extensive logging and road building experience greater fire severity than unlogged, unroaded areas, according to both the Department of the Interior and the Department of Agriculture. "The removal of large, merchantable trees from forests does not reduce fire risk and may, in fact, increase such risk," says a September 2000 report by both departments. A 2001 audit by the Department of Agriculture also reports that "commercial timber sales do not meet the criteria for forest restoration." And U.S. Forest Service fire specialist Denny Truesdale says, "The majority of the material that we need to take out is not commercial timber. It is up to three and four inches in diameter. We can't sell it."

So why is the Forest Service still pressing "fuel reduction" timber sales? Big trees mean big money.
Read the full story


More on wildfires
"We had to destroy the village to save it"
Wildfire Basics: Q&A with Dr. Tim Ingalsbee
Yellowstone: The Vital Role of Wildfires
Solutions: Fire Prevention
U.S. Wildfire History

Forest Voice Fall 2002 Homepage